
Yes, it is possible to generate electricity from the heat energy contained in a block of ice. The graphic shows the setup. Liquid nitrogen boils at 77.36 K and a block if ice is (at most) 273 K. Boiling nitrogen produces pressurized nitrogen gas that escapes through the nozzle and spins a turbine. The turbine spins the generator to produce electricity and lights the bulb.
[NOTE: We are measuring temperatures in “kelvins” (K), which is an absolute temperature scale where 0 K is absolute zero (-272.15 °C) — the coldest temperature possible. FYI, The coldest temperature ever achieved was in 2018, by the QUANTUS Team (DEU) in Bremen, Germany. Their specialized cryogenic equipment hit a record low of -273.149999999962 °C, just 38 trillionths of a degree above absolute zero.]
So a block of ice contains heat energy as long as its temperature is above absolute zero. To calculate the amount of energy available in this hypothetical experiment we need the equation for heat capacity:
Q = mcΔT where
Q = the heat energy measured in joules
m = mass of heat source (1 cubic meter of ice = 917 kg)
c = specific heat of heat source (for ice: 2.11×103 J/kg·K)
ΔT = change in temperature of heat source in absolute Kelvins
For this calculation we need to make two assumptions:
- We have enough liquid nitrogen to run the engine until no more energy is available.
- The liquid nitrogen absorbs heat totally from the ice, with negligible contributions from the air.
When the block of ice cools to 77.36 K the engine will stop. There’s still heat energy in the ice, but its now lower temperature won’t boil liquid nitrogen. The amount of heat energy extracted at this point is:
Q = mcΔT = (917 kg)(2.108×103 J/kg·K)(273 K − 77 K) = 3.8×108 J (106 kWh)
That’s enough energy to keep that 100 W light bulb running for 44 days! Or to put it in a counterintuitive context, that’s enough energy to toast around 5000 slices of bread!
Of course, this not a practical source of energy since it takes 0.5 kWh of electricity to produce a single liter of liquid nitrogen. With a latent heat of evaporation = 199,200 J/kg we would need 1907 kg of liquid nitrogen to extract the amount of heat energy in our hypothetical calculation and cool the block of ice down to 77 K. And that works out to around 1544 liters! You can do the math and see why this is not a practical source of energy.
So what’s the point of even talking about this “ice powered heat engine” if it’s not practical? Answer: Generalization of the heat engine concept to emphasize that any temperature difference can be harnessed to do useful work. This lecture followed the one on the first heat engines and was a logical extension of the topic.
To show you what I mean about the pedagogical value of concept generalization, here’s an interesting anecdote. At the end of this lecture I always posed the question: So after the engine stops running, what has happened to the block of ice? Invariably, the students would answer “It’s melted.” Even though the graphic clearly shows heat flowing from the ice to the liquid nitrogen, the students default to their idea of what “used ice” means, and “used ice” is “melted ice” based on common experience.
The correct answer is: The ice is now much colder than it’s original 273 K. But there’s still heat energy in that colder ice that could be extracted. Problem is, now you’d need to fill the flask with liquid hydrogen, helium, or neon, all of which boil at temperatures less than 70 K.
Next Week in Sky Lights ⇒ Pareidolia Part 3