Q&A: How We Knew Space Was a Vacuum

Question: At what point during the history of science did we discover outer space was a vacuum? I’m pretty sure it was before we actually went there, but when did we know for certain? — MC, Algoma, WI

Answer: Excellent question MC. And the answer is a great example of how science builds on existing knowledge, sometimes in circuitous paths, sometimes to dead ends, but often to new discoveries. The idea that space is a vacuum took centuries to evolve from hypothesis to fact.

But if you’re looking for “absolute proof” it was in the mid-1940s when Germany fired V2 rockets across the English Channel from Peenemünde. These rockets were the first to reach outer space (top graphic). Near the apex of their flight they were observed to move along a ballistic trajectory — motion in which gravity is the sole acting force. Ballistic motion can only happen in a vacuum.

The chart below shows how both atmospheric pressure and density decrease exponentially with altitude. At 100 km most of the atmosphere (99.9999%) is below you. 100 km also marks the Karman Line (shown in the main graphic), generally considered the “official” start of outer space. Above this altitude aerodynamic flight is no longer possible. Wings are useless. Only rocket thrusters and gravity can affect your motion.

V2 rockets could reach 120 km altitude if fired vertically. When launched at targets in England they typically peaked around 80 km, but even at 50 km there’s already a pretty good vacuum.

So it wasn’t until the 1940s that we had incontrovertible proof that space was a vacuum. But scientists in the 1700s were already 99.9999% sure it was. This certainty emerged over centuries of careful observation, thought, and experimentation. Here’s the major steps down that path …

  • Aristotle famously declared “Nature abhors a vacuum” (ca. 350 BCE). It was later argued by Lucretius (ca. 70 BCE) that a vacuum must be possible based on the theory of atomism. If the physical world is composed of discrete parts, then there must be “nothingness” between those parts. This argument was purely philosophical and unsupported by real experiments. Until …
  • … 1643 when Evangelista Torricelli invented the mercury barometer — a device to measure atmospheric pressure. He argued convincingly that the empty space in the tube above the liquid metal must contain at least a partial vacuum. Follow that link to see a diagram of his device.
  • Later that decade Blaise Pascal carried a barometer to the tops of several mountains to test his hypothesis that air pressure decreased with altitude. It did. Extrapolating from that data put the “top” of the atmosphere (the zero pressure altitude) somewhere near 89 km, not far from today’s Karman Line.
  • In 1650 Otto von Guericke invented the mechanical vacuum pump. He later used it for his famous Magdeburg Hemispheres demonstration showing the force of atmospheric pressure acting against an evacuated metal sphere. It was a dramatic demonstration that vacuums (and atmospheric pressure) were real phenomena.
  • The first telescopes were built in the 17th century. As they improved in magnification and resolution, astronomers could see other planets’ atmospheres were limited in spacial extent. Also, improved understanding of the behavior of light led many astronomers to conclude Earth’s atmosphere must be limited in extent — if not, we’d be unable to see the stars.
  • In the 18th century two developments further supported the idea that space was a vacuum. First, Newton’s laws of motion made clear that if space were not a (frictionless) vacuum, then the moons and planets could not move the way they do through space — effectively tracing ballistic trajectories.
  • Second, Newton’s laws combined with then-emerging theories of thermodynamics led to the kinetic theory of gases. This made it possible to model the atmosphere as a shell of gas contained by Earth’s gravity. It predicts there will be a specific altitude where the atmosphere thins out to a vacuum.

So by the end of the 18th century science was fairly certain space was a vacuum, but it would be another 150 years before anything actually got there. The rocket scientists at Peenemünde “aimed” their V2s assuming space was a vacuum and were not surprised by the results. Unfortunately, the residents of England were surprised — when the V2s reentered at supersonic speed giving no audible warning of their imminent impact.

Next Week in Sky Lights ⇒ If Videoconference Apps Corrected Orientation for Location

ISS Over Phoenix v.2